Pikipedia

Pikipedia:Featured article/archived nominations

Project page Discussion
< Pikipedia:Featured article
Revision as of 01:15, August 3, 2012 by PikFan23 (talk | contribs) (Undo revision 70587 by Flare (talk) Uh-uh.)

This is an archive of past nominated articles to be featured. Please do not edit this page.

Featured

These nominated articles became Main Page features.

Super Smash Bros. Brawl

I'm partly doing this to attract attention to it, as the article is probably lacking a lot of the information it could have. Also, I think it's a good article to feature as SSBB's the game of the moment, and it does have a few interesting pictures and bits of writing.GP 15:49, 4 May 2008 (UTC)

Support

  • (Nominator)GP
  • The fact that it isn't about the games themselves annoys me. However, you have convincing points... Heck, I'll give it a yes. It won't hurt anyone.--Prezintenden
  • I support it as long as the discription on the front page says something like "Super Smash Bros. Brawl is a Nintendo Fighting Game in which Olimar is a playable character." 67.172.252.52 01:49, 11 May 2008 (UTC)
    Yeah, it'll be the first paragraph already on the article, plus whatever seems important and well-written from further down.GP 08:04, 11 May 2008 (UTC)
  • Great idea :DDDDDD!~Crystal Lucario~

Oppose

Comments

Scale

I think this is a good article bc it has a lot of info, shows how to solve them, and has good pictures. IAMAHIPO_ocolor 15:49, 27 April 2008 (UTC)

Support

Oppose

  • Booooooring. Scales are lame. Mikeburnfire 03:14, 11 May 2008 (UTC)

Comments

Firstly, I think some bits need rewording, as it's a bit...wordy. After that, I'll reconsider.GP 16:49, 27 April 2008 (UTC)

The Ship

Well-written, adequate images, quite comprehensive.GP

Support

Oppose

Comments

Figwort

Many (3 decent...*cough*) images, as much as you would want to know, even external links. And it's a plant. No plants have been featured yet.GP

Support

Oppose

Comments

Bulbmin

I like Bulbmin because the bulborb-pikmin symbiotic relationship is so unique and compelling, in particular the Juvenile ones you can control. Also, players of Pikmin 2 who stopped playing before encountering them might feel compelled to play it again. 71.205.154.176 23:45, 7 May 2008 (UTC)Mikeburnfire

Support

  • (Nominator)Mikeburnfire
  • I don't see any reason why it shouldn't be featured. IAMAHIPO_ocolor 03:20, 8 May 2008 (UTC)
  • I think bulbmin are awesome an need to be shown. - Jaypikmin
  • This is still here? And I didn't vote?GP
  • They're awsome! PikPikCarrots342
  • They rock! And they rock some more! They're awesome, okay? AFROMAN 15:22, 3 December 2008 (UTC)

Oppose

  • Right, they're the only non-mentioned Pikmin, so I'll count them as a spoiler; as small as it is. It's certainly an article still worth featuring, but not now. --Prezintenden 18:54, 8 May 2008 (UTC)
  • Ditto.~Crystal Lucario~

Comments

Also, would it be possible to split up the Bulbmin topic into "Bulbmin (adult)" and "Bulbmin (Juvenile)"? I know that they are both part of the same species, but their roles as enemies and pikmin are vastly different.

I see no reason why to do so. This discussion was also held here. Adding Bulbmin to the main page is rather spoilish. Do we ignore this fact? I'm not sure to what extent this would spoil.--Prezintenden
Actually, I split the page quite a while back, sorting everything out.GP
Were we talking about splitting it into different pages, or into different sections?--Prezintenden
I think the original suggestion was splitting into 2 pages, then we both said it would be better to split the article, which I did. Then it kind of went away.GP 18:17, 12 May 2008 (UTC)
Fix joo think? I'm ~Crystal Lucario~ And I approve this message.

Caustic Dweevil

'Cause we need to feature something. I just cleaned up the text in this one, but it could do with a new picture. Another option is Red Bulborb.GP

Support

Oppose

Comments

Beady Long Legs

Support

Oppose

Comments

Wistful Wild

Support

  1.  Snakeboss14  Excellent area with awesome music.
  2. RWAR! ~JOSHA ZILLA!!!~ AND IMAFIRINMAHLAZOR!!! Best level in the game with a formal article to prove it, got my vote!
  3. GP
  4. SirPikmin, Your Bold Pikmin KnightContributions

Oppose

Comments

Waterwraith

Support

  • The one and only, Peanut64. The article has detail, a good picture and also features a theroy.
  • --FREAK ~Game  Freak~OUT! Well written and good photos.
  • This is an interesting creature/entity, it should be featured.Falcoz 20:24, January 24, 2010 (UTC)
  • MRPANTS 01:53, March 13, 2010 (UTC) lots of different media and glitches on that page
  •  Snakeboss14  Let's say this wikia has very few users to make this kind of votes. What do you say?

Oppose

Comments

2-Player mode

Lot's of info, we've had Waterwraith way too long.

Support

  • Nominator. Vol (Talk)
  • It could be better, but it's good enough, I guess.GP
  • It's an important part of the game (kinda; well, it's a sub-menu from the main menu. That's important enough). I haven't played Pikmin 2 yet, but I guess that's all the info that's needed to be complete. {EspyoT} 12:53, 21 September 2010 (EDT)
  • The article is very descriptive on 2 player mode. Turtwig A 19:21, 21 September 2010 (EDT)
  • I'm back. And I support. However. as Green said, there are better articles. That being said, this shall suffice. Ridly Roar! 06:23, 22 September 2010 (EDT)
  • It does need some images, though.  Snakeboss14 

Oppose

Comments

Purple Pikmin

Support

  1. The one and only, Peanut64. I nominated this for a new featured Article, and I like the way the article is set up.
  2. GP - Ugh, I guess so. (^Regarding the featured image, I was intending to say we should just have any admin allowed to change it whenever, and users can put ideas on the talk page if they want (as, apparently, I've already stated there).)
  3. {EspyoT} It IS a major part of the game.
  4. 173.74.116.119 Very well writen.
  5. Vol (Talk) Okay, looks good.

Oppose

Comments

Smoky Progg

Support

  1. random creepy guy. I'm nominating this because I think more people shold know about the Smoky Progg, and the article gives lots of information along with some good examples of glitches, battle stratagies, etc.
  2. {EspyoT} Basically, what random creepy guy said.
  3. Vol (Talk) It's better than Purple Pikmin (as in the article).
  4. Prezintenden - Voting for both, are we, Espyo?
  5. GP (^Why not? We need something for after this one.)
  6. Mudkip - Basically, Smoky Progg is a somewhat unknown boss, he's cool, has a cool glitch, the page is better, ETCETERA. Plus, I think White Pikmin are out to get your Golden Pikpik Carrots. EVIL
  7. 173.74.116.119 I'm nominating this because we need to spead the word about this boss.

Oppose

Comments

Mamuta

Support

  1. --Jelloratbob 18:01, 2 May 2011 (EDT)
  2. --Man-at-Legs888 12:14, 15 June 2011 (EDT)
  3. Mrblob1012 (talk • contribs)
  4. The one and only, Peanut64.
  5. GP

Oppose

Comments

Brute Knuckles

Support

  1. .:SkaPunkMan89:. 22:18, 28 July 2011 (EDT) Personally, I think this would be a marvelous addition to the feature article section primary because it's a unique treasure and upgrade that is not obtained normally from bosses and is instead obtained from a Mamuta
  2. {EspyoT} It's a bit different from your standard featured article. Why not?
  3. GP
  4. -- Jelloratbob  17:15, 30 July 2011 (EDT)
  5. FREAK ~Game  Freak~OUT!

Oppose

Comments

If possible, can we get this to be the new FA as soon as possible. Mamuta has been up there for almost 8 months... --FREAK ~Game  Freak~OUT!

Burrowing Snagret

It's a fairly common boss in Pikmin 2, the article contains lots of good information, and it has interesting trivia information as well.

Support

Oppose

Comments

Not featured

These nominated articles did not become Main Page features.

Captain Olimar

He's the main character and has a great article so why not?

Support

  • (Nominator) Bucktooth_Tuba
  • C'mon guys, this is Olimar! Who cares if he's been featured before, he's the main event! I support. Mikeburnfire 20:56, 10 May 2008 (UTC)Mikeburnfire

Oppose

  • Okay, I'm actually going to oppose. Firstly, it's a bit predictable, not exactly a novel feature. Secondly, for one of the main articles, half of it is a retelling of the story of both games. It needs some reorganisation at the very least. Finally...we can't all support everything, as it'd be impossible to choose one.GP 18:13, 8 May 2008 (UTC)
  • Ditto.--Prezintenden
  • Ditto-errrr... trito?~Crystal Lucario~ 12:10, 9 May 2008 (UTC)

Comments

GO GO OLIMAR! I'm Redpikmin Flamethrower And I approve this message.

Burrowing Snagret

A fairly popular enemy, but not as common as the Red Bulborb, for example. Also, it is a boss, but not very spoilish. I think the article is well written too. 67.172.252.52 01:49, 11 May 2008 (UTC)

Support

  • I agree with nominator.IAMAHIPO_ocolor
  • Me too. It's long enough and well-written. Could get a better image and have most of the first bit moved to 'how to kill', though.GP

Oppose

  • I think this has already been feautered about the time I started coming... <.<'~Crystal Lucario~ 12:11, 9 May 2008 (UTC)
    It was agreed that if an article was recently faetured in the auto rotation, it is irrelevant and can be featured now again. I would keep this for the future, as it is a good article.--Prezintenden 13:30, 9 May 2008 (UTC)

Comments

S.S. Dolphin

Okay, think, this was the entire reason Pikmin 1 was started. If The Dolphin hadn't have any pieces blown apart, Olimar would just have blasted off again. Their would be no Olimar meeting Pikmin and the series wouldn't even exist. Pik kid 16:48, 27 June 2008 (UTC)

Support

  • I suppose. It's a bit short, but there's not much else it could have.GP

Oppose

Comments

Emperor Bulblax

For

Against

  • That isn't that great of an artical, it looks like it should be on GameFAQ's and needs major fixing so it isn't purely a guide, and KB72 you should give us reasons... I'm ~Lonely Turret~ And I approve this message.
  • Yeah, it has layout issues and sections aren't divided up very well. Some parts of the text are too long and just look daunting.GP
  • He just ain't cool enough if you ask me. AFROMAN 22:18, 3 December 2008 (UTC)

Comments

Good point...Killer bread bug 72  

White Pikmin

Support

  1. 173.74.116.119 Perfect follow up for purple pikmin.
  2. 96.10.246.39 17:25, 2 May 2011 (EDT) - Fits the style of Pikipedia ;).
  3. Mrblob1012 (talk • contribs) per all

Oppose

  1. Vol (Talk) It's a good article, but it's not fit to be featured.
  2.   Loafy the Breadbug   I don't think it would be very good just to feature Pikmin and Creatures. Instead have something like an Area or Treasure.
  3. Not great for such an important article; everything's just dumped in the first section. GP

Comments

Hocotate ship

Support

  1. ==Ridly   Skree! 17:45, 28 July 2011 (EDT)
  2.   Loafy the Breadbug   Guess so, better than anything else we've come up with.

Oppose

  1. The one and only, Peanut64. I would rather not advertise a major spoiler, the golden ship...
  2. Featured before. GP
  3. --Jelloratbob 13:45, 28 July 2011 (EDT)

Comments

  • This was featured before. Can we nominate previously featured articles? {EspyoT} 17:32, 29 July 2011 (EDT)
  • I'd rather not. Peanut: I wouldn't call it much of a spoiler, but yeah, I see your point. It seems we did actually have that sentence in the feature last time... (At least the image is hidden in the article.) GP
  • Yeah, I looked through the featured articles category but didn't notice that this was featured already. -_- Changing vote. -- Jelloratbob  17:15, 30 July 2011 (EDT)
Retrieved from "https://www.pikminwiki.com/index.php?title=Pikipedia:Featured_article/archived_nominations&oldid=70594"