144
edits
User talk:Kettleonwater: Difference between revisions
no edit summary
(Reply (this was written independently from the one a few minutes ago)) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
::Personally I think it’s way too speculative (although well-written). In P3 and P4, it’s never explicitly stated what caused the crash (and barely hinted to be one object, P3 frames it as a technical malfunction and P4 says nothing), so covering those as if it was an asteroid is too speculative for the wiki. Also, it’s hugely unlikely that it’s the same body each time, as a post-human world would have a whole ton of space junk floating about up there, any of which could be the cause. This would be a good article to put as a userpage subpage, and then you can link out to it (not within the wiki, mind you) when you want to show somebody all the known info on debris orbiting PNF-404. [[User:Supremekirbo|Supremekirbo]] ([[User talk:Supremekirbo|talk]]) 05:51, September 3, 2023 (EDT) | ::Personally I think it’s way too speculative (although well-written). In P3 and P4, it’s never explicitly stated what caused the crash (and barely hinted to be one object, P3 frames it as a technical malfunction and P4 says nothing), so covering those as if it was an asteroid is too speculative for the wiki. Also, it’s hugely unlikely that it’s the same body each time, as a post-human world would have a whole ton of space junk floating about up there, any of which could be the cause. This would be a good article to put as a userpage subpage, and then you can link out to it (not within the wiki, mind you) when you want to show somebody all the known info on debris orbiting PNF-404. [[User:Supremekirbo|Supremekirbo]] ([[User talk:Supremekirbo|talk]]) 05:51, September 3, 2023 (EDT) | ||
::While the asteroid is important, I don't think it's ''that'' important to justify an entire article about it. Besides, it couldn't be just one asteroid doing all this, it would have to be multiple, and that makes it more a feature of PNF-404 than of an asteroid. Also, it's way too speculative to say that every single crash in ''Pikmin 4'' was because of an asteroid just because some asteroids are visible in the ending cutscene. I think that the non-speculative contents of this article could be merged into the [[PNF-404]] article, but if you want to keep the page as it is, it can also be moved to the userspace so it's no longer an official article, by renaming the page to [[User:Kettleonwater/PNF-404's asteroid]] for example. — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 05:55, September 3, 2023 (EDT) | ::While the asteroid is important, I don't think it's ''that'' important to justify an entire article about it. Besides, it couldn't be just one asteroid doing all this, it would have to be multiple, and that makes it more a feature of PNF-404 than of an asteroid. Also, it's way too speculative to say that every single crash in ''Pikmin 4'' was because of an asteroid just because some asteroids are visible in the ending cutscene. I think that the non-speculative contents of this article could be merged into the [[PNF-404]] article, but if you want to keep the page as it is, it can also be moved to the userspace so it's no longer an official article, by renaming the page to [[User:Kettleonwater/PNF-404's asteroid]] for example. — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 05:55, September 3, 2023 (EDT) | ||
:::Just looked through a few dialogue trees in ''Pikmin 4''. Mika mentions a "loud noise" before the tourist ship crashed, and Olimar explicitly says "I never imagined that a meteorite would hit the ship". I think this serves as confirmation for P4. Honestly, I named the article after a single asteroid because it's way more intruiging to think it's all the result of the same thing, like it has some weird will of its own. I still think it is worthy of actual inclusion on this wiki, and so I'll retool the article a tiny bit, "PNF-404's asteroid field" is probably a better name. [[User:Kettleonwater|Kettleonwater]] ([[User talk:Kettleonwater|talk]]) | |||