Pikipedia:Canon policy: Difference between revisions

From Pikipedia, the Pikmin wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Espyo moved page Pikipedia:Canon to Pikipedia:Canon policy without leaving a redirect)
m (Changed protection settings for "Pikipedia:Canon policy" ([Edit=Allow only autoconfirmed users] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite)))
 
(19 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{shortcut|P:CANON}}
This policy pertains to the [[canon]] information on the wiki, particularly its coverage scope. Because of the wild nature of video games and their content, a distinction must be settled so that non-canon information is not written as canon.
This policy pertains to the [[canon]] information on the wiki, particularly its coverage scope. Because of the wild nature of video games and their content, a distinction must be settled so that non-canon information is not written as canon.


Line 14: Line 15:


{| style="width: 75%; margin: 0 auto;" class="wikitable"
{| style="width: 75%; margin: 0 auto;" class="wikitable"
! style="width: 33%; color: #800;" | Bad
! style="width: 33%; color: #800;" | Too literal
! style="width: 33%; color: #880;" | So-so
! style="width: 33%; color: #080;" | Good
! style="width: 33%; color: #080;" | Good
! style="width: 33%; color: #800;" | Too fictional
|-
|-
| Real world perspective
| style="text-align: center;" | Real-world perspective
| In-universe perspective
| style="text-align: center;" | Mixed perspective
| Mixed perspective
| style="text-align: center;" | In-universe perspective
|-
|-
| style="text-align: center;" | "[[Burgeoning Spiderwort]]s are fictional, virtual plants that debuted in the video game ''[[Pikmin 2]]''."
| style="text-align: center;" | "[[Burgeoning Spiderwort]]s are fictional, virtual plants that debuted in the video game ''[[Pikmin 2]]''."
| style="text-align: center;" | "Burgeoning Spiderworts are plants discovered by [[Captain Olimar]] during his second trip to [[PNF-404]]."
| style="text-align: center;" | "Burgeoning Spiderworts are plants that debuted in ''Pikmin 2''."
| style="text-align: center;" | "Burgeoning Spiderworts are plants that debuted in ''Pikmin 2''."
| style="text-align: center;" |  "Burgeoning Spiderworts are plants discovered by [[Captain Olimar]] during his second trip to [[PNF-404]]."
|-
|-
| It is obvious that the article won't be detailing any plants in real life, and that ''Pikmin 2'' is a game. Pikipedia is a wiki about a fictional franchise, so naturally, it should be expected for the content within to be fictional. Explaining that the subject is not real is almost condescending, and could add unnecessary [[wikipedia:Purple prose|purple prose]].
| It is obvious that the article won't be detailing any plants in real life, and that ''Pikmin 2'' is a game. Pikipedia is a wiki about a fictional franchise, so naturally, it should be expected for the content within to be fictional. Explaining that the subject is not real is almost condescending, and could add unnecessary [[wikipedia:Purple prose|purple prose]].
| This example both explains the plants as if they were as canon as a real plant, while still implying that they're virtual. No extra words are needed, the text feels right from an in-universe perspective, and is still useful and comfortable to real world readers..
| Although this is true, it doesn't help the reader understand exactly when the plants debuted. The information is a part of the canon, but the readers are still humans in the real world, and it is more convenient to explain the information with that in mind.
| Although this is true, it doesn't help the reader understand exactly when the plants debuted. The information is a part of the canon, but the readers are still humans in the real world, and it is more convenient to explain the information with that in mind.
| This example both explains the plants as if they were as canon as a real plant, while still implying that they're virtual. No extra words are needed, the text feels right from an in-universe perspective, and is still useful and comfortable to real world readers.
|}
|}


Line 43: Line 44:


==Conflicts==
==Conflicts==
Because the ''Pikmin'' games are developed by [[Nintendo EAD]] in Japan, the Japanese [[Region|version]] of a game is technically more canon than the remaining versions. However, because Pikipedia is an English wiki, it considers the information on the American version more canon than the Japanese version. The European version comes second. For instance, it is more canonical that Captain Olimar recovered a [[Abstract Masterpiece|Snapple lid]] on the sixth sublevel of the [[Shower Room]] than it is to say that he recovered a [[Plentiful Tank|Breitsamer honey jar]]; that, in turn, is more canonical than saying he recovered an Ohayo milk cover.
Because the ''Pikmin'' games are developed by {{w|Nintendo EAD}} in Japan, the Japanese [[Region|version]] of a game is technically more canon than the remaining versions. However, because Pikipedia is an English wiki, it considers the information on the American version more canon than the Japanese version. The European version comes second. For instance, it is more canonical that Captain Olimar recovered a [[Abstract Masterpiece|Snapple lid]] on the sixth sublevel of the [[Shower Room]] than it is to say that he recovered a [[Plentiful Tank|Breitsamer honey jar]]; that, in turn, is more canonical than saying he recovered an Ohayo milk cover.


{{policy}}
{{policies}}
[[Category:Policies]]

Latest revision as of 08:29, April 29, 2024

Shortcut:
P:CANON

This policy pertains to the canon information on the wiki, particularly its coverage scope. Because of the wild nature of video games and their content, a distinction must be settled so that non-canon information is not written as canon.

Scope

Pikipedia documents information regarding the Pikmin franchise, but unless otherwise specified, it is all canon. There are three rough "degrees" of canon:

  • Pure canon: The information is objectively true in the context of the Pikmin universe.
  • Objectionable canon: The information comes from a source quite close to the universe's canon, but it cannot be definitely considered canon. It does not contradict with any canon sources, so it is normally accepted as official.
  • Non-canon: The information is not true in the Pikmin universe. It is included on Pikipedia purely for trivial, complementary or completion purposes.

For the most part, Pikipedia takes interest in documenting the facts that happen in the games and other media, regardless of their canon. Nevertheless, this policy helps distinguish the canonical value of some elements in the series, for the purpose of giving the Pikmin universe a sense of definition, and to clearly distinguish content that should not be considered canon by readers interested in the universe's lore. For a list of what elements count as what, see the canon article.

Marking

Pure canon

Pure canon content must not be marked, and must be said as if it were something in real life, while still acknowledging the fact that it is a game.

Too literal Good Too fictional
Real-world perspective Mixed perspective In-universe perspective
"Burgeoning Spiderworts are fictional, virtual plants that debuted in the video game Pikmin 2." "Burgeoning Spiderworts are plants that debuted in Pikmin 2." "Burgeoning Spiderworts are plants discovered by Captain Olimar during his second trip to PNF-404."
It is obvious that the article won't be detailing any plants in real life, and that Pikmin 2 is a game. Pikipedia is a wiki about a fictional franchise, so naturally, it should be expected for the content within to be fictional. Explaining that the subject is not real is almost condescending, and could add unnecessary purple prose. This example both explains the plants as if they were as canon as a real plant, while still implying that they're virtual. No extra words are needed, the text feels right from an in-universe perspective, and is still useful and comfortable to real world readers.. Although this is true, it doesn't help the reader understand exactly when the plants debuted. The information is a part of the canon, but the readers are still humans in the real world, and it is more convenient to explain the information with that in mind.

Objectionable canon

Sections or articles that detail material with objectionable canon should start with {{nocanon|y}}. This creates the following box:

This article or section features debatable canonical information.
The content here is yet to be confirmed to be canon, but features non-canonical aspects.

Non-canon

Sections or articles about non-canon content should begin with {{nocanon}}. This code creates the following box:

This article or section features non-canonical information.

Fan content

Fan-created content is not canon and, for the most part, is not accepted on Pikipedia. In addition, fan-created theories are also non canon, but may provide an explanation over something that is. Some fan-made content can follow the known canon perfectly, but unless it is useful to complement canon information, it should not go on the wiki. For the purpose of gathering fan-made ideas and content, the Pikmin Fanon wiki was created.

Conflicts

Because the Pikmin games are developed by Nintendo EAD in Japan, the Japanese version of a game is technically more canon than the remaining versions. However, because Pikipedia is an English wiki, it considers the information on the American version more canon than the Japanese version. The European version comes second. For instance, it is more canonical that Captain Olimar recovered a Snapple lid on the sixth sublevel of the Shower Room than it is to say that he recovered a Breitsamer honey jar; that, in turn, is more canonical than saying he recovered an Ohayo milk cover.